Published: 16 November 2026
With decision 27541, published on 22 October 2026, the Italian Court of Cassation has intervened on the issue of the constitution of company union representatives (RSA), clarifying the criteria used to ascertain the comparatively greater representativeness of trade unions for the purposes of art. 19 of the Workers’ Statute.
This ruling is particularly important in light of Constitutional Court decision 156/2025, which recognised the possibility of constituting company union representatives also in the context of the comparatively more representative union organisations at a national level, thus introducing an autonomous legitimation criterion, an alternative to the signing of the collective agreement applied in the production unit and participation in related negotiations.
The Supreme Court clarifies, first, that greater comparative representativeness must be ascertained with an overall and comparative evaluation of the representative capacity of the union organisation, referring to the productive sector in which the company or production unit concerned operates and conducted on a national scale.
The sector of reference must be identified on the basis of the activity actually carried out by the company, as resulting from the Chamber of Commerce Register of Companies and other classifications, such as the ATECO code, corporate purpose, social security framework, VAT number attribution certificate, and the collective bargaining agreement considered by INPS for the purpose of identifying the minimum contribution, provided these are consistent with the business actually carried out. Whereas the category identified by the collective bargaining agreement is not necessarily important, since it cannot constitute, in itself, the comparison group.
As for the measurement criteria, the Court of Cassation identifies as a priority parameter, the average, with equal weighting, between the percentage of members and that of votes, where both are available, homogeneous, reliable, and referable to the same sector and period. In particular, the percentage of members is expressed by the membership or proxies conferred for the payment of union contributions, while the percentage of votes consists of the votes obtained in union representative elections.
The average thus determined must be compared with the average of representativeness, calculated using the same criterion, expressed by the unions who have signed the so-called leader collective agreement in the sector of reference, identified by the Court as the threshold of comparative representativeness necessary for recognition of the requirement.
The Court also specifies that:
- should the percentage of votes be missing or incomplete, this does not prevent assessment of representativeness, which entails comparison of the percentage of members with the corresponding average of representativeness of the unions that have signed the leader collective agreement;
- the minimum threshold of 5% provided for admission to national collective bargaining in the field of public employment and the interconfederal system is not automatically applied;
- the requirement of comparatively higher representativeness can be recognised to a plurality of union organisations, without the need for the absolute prevalence of one over the others, provided each expresses an effective, stable, qualified, and comparatively predominant representative capacity in the sector considered on a national scale;
- merely corporate, local, marginal, or episodic representativeness is not sufficient;
- the comparatively greater representativeness must exist at the time of the workers’ initiative to establish the RSA.
Of particular interest is the further clarification regarding burden of proof. The Court of Cassation affirms that it is up to the union organisation claiming the right to establish an RSA to attach and demonstrate the existence, at the time of the workers’ initiative, of the requirement of comparatively greater representativeness. Proof may be provided by any suitable means, including simple presumptions, provided it is based on serious, precise, concordant elements, as well as on homogeneous data regarding the productive sector, the national scope, and the reference period.
Toffoletto De Luca Tamajo is at your disposal should you need any further clarification and/or details.